Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men Wiki Guide 3

Red Dead Redemption 2

PlayStation 4 Xbox One

Red Dead Redemption II Gold Medal Walkthrough: A Fisher of Men Story Mission

Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men is a story mission which introduces you to the fishing side-activity. In Red Dead Redemption II, knowing how to fish is necessary not only for achieving Total Completion but also for earning more money.

RDR2 A Fisher of Men is available starting Chapter 2, and getting the Gold Medal is quite easy; assuming you know how to fish in the video game developed by Rockstar Studios.

Are you ready to go fishing, Arthur? Let’s go!


“Arthur does a favor for Abigail and takes Jack out on a fishing trip.”

Mission Requirements:

Gold Medal Goals:

  • After arriving at the river, catch a fish within one minute and 30 seconds
  • Complete the mission within seven minutes and 20 seconds


Start by talking to Abigail at Horseshoe Overlook. She asks you to do her a favor and try to spend some time with little Jack.

Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men Wiki Guide 1

Talk to Abigail to start A Fisher of Men

And there is no better way to do that than fishing. Do you like fishing? Good then!

Go find Jack playing around in the camp.

Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men Wiki Guide 2

Take little Jack with you on a fishing trip

The little boy is quite excited to go fishing with you. Mount your horse and wait for Jack to come along. Now, ride south-west of Caliban’s Seat with little Jack.

As you arrive, you will receive a Companion Request from Jack. We’ll deal with it later.

Approach the shore marked on your map and equip the fishing rod form the item menu. Now, it’s time to pick the bait. Cheese is perfect for the fish we want to catch.

Awesome! Here is how to fish in Red Dead Redemption 2.

After you equip the rod and the bait, pull L2/LT and cast the fishing line by pressing R2/RT. Now, it’s time to wait until the fish bites the bait. You will know when it does because your controller will start shaking.

The moment you feel the controller moving, press and release R2/RT.

Fishing in RDR2 has 2 sequences. The first one starts when the fish is fighting.  During this phase, you need to tilt the left thumbstick in the opposite direction. For example, if the fish is moving right, you will move the left thumbstick to the left. Keep in mind that if you reel during this phase, you will break the line.

The second phase starts when the fish is tired. This is your chance to bring the fish closer to the shore by moving the left thumbstick down (towards you) and constantly rotating the right thumbstick clockwise. When the controller starts shaking stop reeling because the first phase begins.

Repeat both sequences until the fish is close enough for Arthur to pick it up.

Now that you know how to fish, back to the mission.

Gold Medal Goal Tip: Both Gold Medal requirements in this mission are very easy to achieve, as long as you know how to fish. There are no tricks or tips and you should be able to fulfill both of them on your first try.

Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men Wiki Guide 3

Not the biggest fish, but it’s a start

After you catch your first fish, continue to cast your line, as the goal of this mission is to catch 3. Once you get all three, a cutscene will start and you’ll return to Jack.

The boy is already bored, so you two need to return home. But before you go, you’ll encounter to detectives sent by the Pinkertons in Blackwater. Don’t worry cowboy, they’re not here after you. Is Dutch they want.

Red Dead Redemption 2 A Fisher of Men Wiki Guide 3

Looks like Dutch’s gang has been found

Once you talk to them, and politely refuse their offer, you should hurry back to your camp. Dutch needs to know that Horseshoe Overlook isn’t safe anymore.

As you approach the camp, A Fisher of Men ends. Don’t know what to do next? Check our Red Dead Redemption 2 Wiki for the complete list of missions and side activities.

Finally, if you have questions, post them below or find us on FacebookTwitter, and Instagram.

Founder and senior content producer at PrimeWikis, I am the former CEO of I've been playing video games since 1994, and I like to keep up with the latest video game releases. Feel free to get in touch with me if gaming is your passion.